Q.2 (b) Bring out the pattern of commercialization of agriculture in the 19th Century. Was it a forced process for the vast majority of poorer peasants?
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
Commercialization of agriculture was the process of transformation of agriculture from a subsistence way of living to commercial business enterprise.
Causes of agriculture commercialization
1. Revenue settlements - It not only extracted maximum surplus but also aid in the creation of private property Eg.) Permament Settlement, Ryotwari etc. 2. Judicial structure and laws also favoured zamindars and planters against poor farmers. 3. European investment and immigration into lucrative plantation business 4. Use of political force - laws were passed to benefit planters (eg inland emmigration act). Also peasants coerced by planters to cultivate cash crops. 5. Expansion of railways - aided in the massive import-export of raw material to Europe.
Pattern of Commercialization
1. The food crops such as rice, wheat was discouraged. 2. Commercial crops -such as jute, tea, indigo, coffee encouraged. 3. European immigration and investment led to large scale plantations in tea, indigo. Eg.) Tea plantations in darjeeling 4. Arrangements such as Timkathia system ensured a steady supply of indigo the planters in Bengal. 5. Similary, opium was grown in Bihar to expand trade with china.
Was it a forced process?
1. The planters used lathiyals, government support to force peasants to grow indigo in Bengal. 2. Also, forced dispossessions and indeltedness of farmers compelled them to grow cash crops. 3. Madras Torture Commission report highlighted the large scale torture of peasants in order to force them to accept unfavourable settlements. 4. However, Tapan Raychaudhary also highlighted the personal motive of farmers in commercial farming 5. He argued that the high prices and profit of cash crops encouraged rich peasants to undertake cash crop farming. 6. But since for the poor peasants, the profit was kept by planters, this process was generally forced. An adverse impact of commercialization was the exacerbation of famines in India due to shortage of food crops.