Q.7 (c) Discuss the applicability of Segmentary State Model for Chola state. How other models tried to explain the nature of the Chola kingdom? [20 Marks]
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
The medieval cholas established a vast empire in the South India during 10th - 12th century giving rise to widespread debate as to the nature of the state polity.
[a small boxed sketch map of the southern tip of the Indian peninsula with the area shaded by hatching, labelled "Cholas"]
Applicability of Segmentary state model for Cholas
Popularized by Burton Stein, it gave a highly decentralized model of chola empire.
features 1. Sacral kingship - The king only acted as a ritual head and wielded not effective power over the entire area. 2. Absence of permanent army, navy and bureaucracy - It was dependent on its vassal for army and day to day work. 3. Dependence on plunder and wars for resources as there was no permanent revenue due to lack of bureaucracy. 4. Pyramidal power structure with king at top and local chiefs practicing real power at bottom.
5. With increasing distance from the centre, the power of king reduced and that of local chiefs increased
[concentric circles with a hatched centre; an arrow from the centre labelled "King real power", an arrow to the right labelled "King", and a downward arrow labelled "nominal power"]
However, this model has been criticized by many historians due to infeasible state structure and contrary to archaeological sources.
other models of chola state
1. Highly centralized empire - As per K.A.N. Sastri, chola state was highly centralized as it had a large army, navy and vast bureaucracy. - However it has a nationalist tinge and thus is rejected by some historians. 2. Karashima refuted Sastri highly centralized model but pointed to centralizing tendencies because of large beaurracy known from inscriptions. 3. Local self government within Chola empire. - (a) As per this theory, the empire consisted of large number of villages (Nadus) looking after day to day work and functioning under broad chola Supervision. - (b) Uttaramerur inscription denote both autonomy of Sabha (Taniyur) and its interaction with chola state. - (c) Currently this model is the most widely accepted.
Thus, more intensive research on this topic is required to bring out the clear picture about chola state.