Topper Copies

Q.4 (c) Why Alexander's invasion of India proved ineffective? Can his invasion be called non-event in the Indian history? [20 Marks]

Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023

Macedonian invasion of India under Alexander took place during 327-26 BCE. The imperialist historians have often exaggerated its impact on the Indian history. However modern study points otherwise.

Reason for ineffectiveness of Alexander's invasion

1. Alexander was able to conquer only North West fringes upto Beas and never entered India formally. 2. This was due to the revolt within his army which faced fatigue and frustration due to long drawn campaign with no end in sight. 3. Alexandrian invasion had minimal Political impact on the subcontinent as the major kingdoms (like Magadha) still ruled. 4. Alexander was not able to retain his empire. As soon as he returned, the empire disintegrated into various Satrapy. 5. Moreover, it had minimal contact with Indian society, culture, religion. Thus no visible impact of invasion can be seen.

Invasion as non-event ?

Despite its ineffectiveness, it cannot be termed as non-event as it provided valuable contribution in other fields.

1. Impetus to trade - It opened many land and sea trade routes between Indian and Europe. Established direct 1st Indo-European contact. 2. Coinage - It improved the coinage to a significant degree which later Indo-greeks, Kushanas adopted. 3. Assimilation of Yavanas in Indian society. It led to Indo greek rule in North west for 3-4 centuries. 4. Gandhara art - It gave rise to syncretism between Indian and Graeco-roman art form in the later centuries. 5. Historiography of India - Accurate dating of events by Herodotus put the events in India into perspective. 6. Details about Indian society – as recorded by foreigners such as Megasthenes. - Eg. Description of Sati for the 1st time found. 7. Transfer of knowledge, culture – India gained knowledge of greek, roman astronomy, astrology, metallurgy, drama culture etc - Eg. Drama curtain in Sanskrit called "Yavana."

Therefore, a balanced, cautious treatment of past events like alexander's invasion is required putting facts and myths at an appropriate place.