Topper Copies

Q.4 (a) The word 'Dhamma figures prominently in the Edicts of Asoka. Is he justified in calling them Dhamma-lipi? Elucidate. [15 Marks]

Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023

Dhamma-lipi were a set of ashokan edicts issuing guidelines for ideal social code of conduct in the society. Let us analyze the various aspect of 'Dhamma'

Various features of Dhamma

1. Ban on animal sacrifice — Rock Edict 1 2. Ban on religious and festival rituals. 3. Respect to parents, relatives, stranger, and even slaves, servants → Rock Edict 9 4. Respect towards Brahmanas, Shramanas 5. Ashoka's personal experience in Kalinga war — Rock Edict 13 6. Duties of king - planting trees, digging well — Rock Edict 2

Various interpretations of Dhamma

1. Harāprasad Shastri — considered it anti-brahmanical and imposition of buddhist ideals 2. R.S. Sharma considers as an ideal social code and is not a narrow sectarian faith. It aimed to promote religious tolerance and harmony. 3. Romila Thapar considers it as a political tool to weld different sections together and aggrandize state's power 4. Upinder Singh highlighted the Buddhist core in Dhamma and thus was definitely inspired by Buddhism

The Verdict

Despite various motives and intentions dhamma had certain Buddhist dhamma principles like — 1. Ahimsa (Non - violence) 2. Respect for all - from different Varnas, race, religion. 3. Critique of brahmanical sacrifices

Hence more than anything it aimed at preaching buddhist principles suited to contemporary needs and included various Ashokan innovations.

Thus Ashoka is justified in calling it 'Dhamma lipi'