Topper Copies

Q.7 (c) How far is it correct to say that the Indians of the ancient period indulged only metaphysical things and not in the development of pure sciences?

Rajendra Bishnoi, AIR 161, 2023

This debate that indians of the ancient period indulge only in metaphysical things and had no sense of History and never paid attention to pure science was put forward by Al- Beruni in medieval time and later pushed ahead by colonial historians. Colonial historians wanted to justify their rule and subject mentally as well.

Ancient Indian literature like Vedas, Upanishads, Buddhist literature, the Ramayana, Puranas etc. focused mainly on metaphysical things like god, soul, life, death - birth etc.. And abundence of this type of literature led to belief that Indians only indulged in metaphysical thigs, which is not true. Because,

1. During Ancient Indian time from Harappan civilisation to 9th century AD, there are lot of evidences of pure science. - (a) Grid and drainage system of IVC was based on scientific method. - (b) Different colors on NBPW, PGW, BRW pottery also evidence of chemical knowledge. - (c) Aryabhatta in Aryabhatiya talked about astronomy, invention of zero, Calculus etc. - (d) Charak's Charaksamhita and Shushrut's shushrutsamhita speaks highly about medical and biological knowledge. - (e) Bhaskar and Brahmgupta's work in the field of astronomy and astrology are exemplary.

So we can say that it is incorrect to say ancient Indians only indulged in Metaphysical things. Although after 8th - 9th century pure science declined and became a close society but there are no doubt that development of pure science was there during ancient time.