Topper Copies

Q.4 (b) Discuss the nature of Ashoka's Dhamma. Was it responsible for the downfall of his empire?

Rajendra Bishnoi, AIR 161, 2023

After the Conquest in Kalinga war, Ashoka was deeply affected by wrath and death of people in war. After this Ashoka announced his Dhemma policy. Dhemma derived from Sanskrit word ' Dharma'.

Different historians have different views about the nature of Ashoka's Dhemma. 1. J. Fleet and H.C. Raychaudhari said that Dhemma was a new religion. 2. Romila Thappar argued that Ashoka's Dhemma was a soft power skill which was used for political aggrandizement. 3. Historians like RG Bhandarkar and Puselkar termed Dhemma as new form of Buddhism 4. Some other historians like K.A.N Sastri, RS Sharma termed this as the crux of all religions.

True nature of Dhamma

Ashoka in 2nd of his pillar edict that "what is Dhamma?" and later in 7th pillar answer this question. Ashoka defined do's and don't of his Dhamma policy. In DO's, he included truth, benevolence, kindness, integrity, non-violence etc. and in Don't, he included stealing, violence, lust, greed etc.

So in a way we can say that the Ashoka's Dhamma was an ethical and moral tool to guide and empower Citizens.

Responsible for downfall of empire

Some Historians argued that Dhamma policy led to decline of Mauryan empire because he gave up on wars and donated too much which worsened his economic resources. He also other ignored issues like security of empire and only focussed on Dhamma.

But critical examination points out that Ashoka never disbanded his Army. Even 50 years after the Ashoka's death Mauryan empire declined in 185 BC. The theory of Brahmanical reaction is also not true.

The truth is that able ruler like Ashoka, only can manage Dhamma policy. Later rulers failed to understand this and were not qualified enough to manage.