Delimitation of seats is essential to ensure fair representation and uphold the principles of 'one vote, one value'. Highlighting the challenges posed by misrepresentation in constituencies analyze the ramifications of population-based delimitation in creating federal tension.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
Delimitation is the process of setting the boundaries of territorial constituencies, to ensure "one person, one vote, one value".
Delimitation in India is carried out by a high-powered Delimitation Commission (Article 82), after parliament enacts an act to that effect, after each census. However, the process of national-level changes is currently frozen as per the 1971 census, according to the 84th amendment.
Challenges posed by misrepresentation 1. Against principles of democracy: "one vote - one value" 2. Under-representation of weaker sections which may not have reservations (eg: religious minorities, OBC population, etc) → less share in representatives, as a % of their population 3. Allegations of "veto" to minority population, in certain cases (eg: allegations of "veto" to minority population in Assam and West Bengal) 4. Dilution of civic responsibility: if people are under-represented, they are less likely to hold representatives accountable 5. Compromise to good governance: a low representative-to-population ratio leads to lesser efficiency, a disconnect between legislators and public, and a lack of citizen participation — so good governance is compromised
Ramifications of population-based delimitation in creating federal tension 1. Madras High Court in the Tenkasi Assembly case: states cannot be penalized for implementing family planning policies — Tamil Nadu should receive compensation of Rs 5600 cr for the reduction in its Lok Sabha seats from 41 to 39 2. Constitutional restriction on number of seats — 550 in Lok Sabha and 250 in Rajya Sabha — makes a constitutional amendment necessary 3. Implications on fiscal federalism: concerns over finance commissions not taking demographic performance into account 4. Concerns w.r.t Rajya Sabha: domination by more populous states dilutes federalism 5. Rise of inter-state disputes: threat to unity of the nation
Thus, the delimitation exercise must be innovatively done, to balance "one-vote, one-value" and also not penalize states that have focused on population control.