Topper Copies

Q.8 (c) Delineate the rise of Feudalism during the period of later Guptas and discuss its main features. [20 Marks]

Kritika Bhardwaj, AIR 370, 2023

The origins of 'Indian feudalism' can be traced to landgrants to Brahmans, temples and even state officials from the Gupta time period onwards (4th-5th centuries CE) - consequently linking political power to [land].

Rise of Indian feudalism

With the works of scholars like D.D. Koshambi, R.S Sharma, BNS Yadava → the focus of historiography shifted to the interrelationship between economy, society, polity → thus, the model of Indian feudalism.

Reasons

1. Political : The politico-administrative set up of this age was revolving around land (e.g. land grants by Guptas to 'Samanta'. This fuelled the process of 'feudalism from above' (D.N Jha, R.S Sharma) D.D. Kosambi. 2. Economic : Theory of urban decay → by 450 CE, an economic decline was clearly visible in the Gupta empire. Trade had declined due to fall of Roman empire ~467 CE ; discovery of Sericulture in Europe ; Huna invasions etc. - thus, society became increasingly agrarian.

3. Social : With the decline in trade and commerce, status of vaishyas declined and that of Shudras improved. Moreover, according to Kali Age Crisis Theory it was argued that - land grants to Brahmans were a way to retain Brahman-Kshatriya dominance in the society → which fuelled feudalism. 4. Cultural aspects - The grants to temples and Brahmanas coincided with the development of Bhakti tradition that emphasised on loyalty, devotion, Surrender to God. This also strengthened feudal loyalty to overlord.

This 'Indian feudalism' model has been challenged by revisionist school (like B.D Chattopadhyay) who believed that it was incorrect to see society in bipolar terms of landlords & peasants. Moreover, Segmentary state model of Burton Stein argued that while political authority was decentralised but ritual sovereignty was not.