Topper Copies

Discuss the impact of direct and indirect farm subsidies on the agriculture sector in India. How have Minimum Support Prices (MSP) affected the agricultural economy?

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

Approximately ~5 lakh crore is spent on agriculture subsidies annually by the Union govt, and much more indirectly, and also by the States.

Direct subsidies

| Subsidy | Impact | |---|---| | MSP | discussed separately below | | PM-KISAN (direct cash transfer) | Positive: income support. Negative: inflationary; diverted for non-agri purposes by the men of the household | | Electricity | Positive: allows pumps etc to be run for irrigation. Negative: discom losses; excess groundwater extraction | | Loan waivers | Positive: none. Negative: "moral hazard" (Urjit Patel); "strategic defaulting" (Economic Survey) | | Insurance (eg. Fasal Bima Yojana) | Negative: none. Positive: safeguarded from pre/post-harvest losses | | Interest subvention (4% + 3%) | Negative: none. Positive: helps in formal credit, reducing the impact of moneylenders | | Machinery (eg. Happy Seeder) | Negative: none. Positive: helps decrease cost of production/increase yield | | Subsidy for organic farming, millets, etc | Positive: helps in crop diversification, rebuilding soil health, etc | | Infra subsidies (eg. Kisan Sampada, Operation Greens for TOP) | Positive: linkages of food processing with agriculture, value addition, prevents distress sale | | Agri research and development (11x multiplier effect) | Highest multiplier effect among all Union govt expenditure: extremely positive | | Agri extension services | Positive: awareness, training, support, handholding |

Indirect subsidies

| Subsidy | Impact | |---|---| | Water (free) | Positive: irrigation. Negative: groundwater exploitation; groundwater pollution | | Fertilizer (~Rs 1.75 lakh cr, the highest) | Positive: none. Negative: promotes overuse, diversion of urea, eutrophication and pollution |

MSP: impact on the agri economy

Positive: 1. Prevents distress sale 2. Sends a price signal to the market

Negative: 1. Structural inflation: MSP increased every year, vegetables/pulses etc ignored, India imports 25% of its pulses 2. Discriminatory: the Shanta Kumar committee found only 5.8% of farmers use MSP, mostly large farmers 3. Distortion in the agri economy 4. Adverse impact on food security: protein not part of the diet due to shortage of pulses 5. Wastage due to poor storage at FCI 6. Environmental harm due to excess water/fertilizer use

Thus, the Economic Survey has said: "Government intervention has harmed more than helped" (for MSP).