Topper Copies

"Indian society in early medieval India was not static but extremely vibrant and responsive to changes taking place at that time." Comment.

Rajendra Bishnoi, AIR 161, 2023

Al- Beruni who visited India in the first half of 11th century, commented in his book "Kitab-ul-Hind" that Indian society in early medieval India was static. He said, "Indians think that there is no country like theirs, no science like theirs, No society like their and no state like theirs". Further he described Indian society as highly stratified, closed and stagnated with compare to other countries and societies in the world.

This criticism by Al-Beruni was supported by the orientalist historians like James Mill, V. A. Smith etc. But it was countered by the nationalist historians like MG Ranade, Rajendra Mitra, RG Bhandarkar etc. They argued that Al-Beruni's comment were biased and exaggerated in nature. They pointed out that society was extremely vibrant and responsive to changes taking place at that time.

Critical analysis

- Indian society in early medieval age was not completely static. because it was open to new changes like trade was in surplus, and people followed their duties and peace was prevalent. - Al-Beruni termed caste system as static society, but it was there for ages. - Indian society had no system like Purdah in early medieval age.

But all in all, early medieval society was not very developed, Rigid caste system, Child marriage, Brahman orthodoxy was dominated and this proves costly for India in centuries to come.

Historian like Satish Chandra commented that social limitation was an important factor in loss of Rajputes against Muhammad Ghori.