Topper Copies

The doctrine of Parliamentary sovereignty and judicial supremacy has exerted considerable influence in shaping the constitutional frameworks of India and the USA. Citing relevant case laws discuss the role of the judiciary in influencing the constitutions in these countries. Is the scope of judicial review wider in India?

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

In India, there is no strict separation of powers, and hence the doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty and judicial supremacy co-exist in India, w.r.t separation of functions, i.e.:

separation of powers (in India) = separation of functions + checks and balances

Whereas in the USA, there is an explicit doctrine of judicial supremacy. However, in the USA too, parliamentary sovereignty and judicial supremacy clash (eg: Obamacare, Roe v Wade), as they do in India (eg: NJAC, etc).

Role of judiciary in influencing the constitution of India 1. Basic Structure Doctrine → Kesavananda Bharati case: limits to the amending power of parliament, i.e. limits to "parliamentary sovereignty" 2. Minerva Mills case: supremacy of judicial independence, upholding the power of judicial review — "everything in India is under judicial review" 3. Maneka Gandhi case: foundation for expansion of Article 21, from "procedure established by law" to "due process of law" 4. SR Bommai judgement: role in influencing federalism, scope of Article 356, etc 5. "First generation" human rights: work (Olga Tellis case), education (Mohini Jain case), right against exploitation (Nilabati Behara case, etc) 6. "Second generation" rights cases: environment (Subhash Kumar case, Vellore Citizens Forum case), privacy (Justice Puttaswamy case), and the Navtej Singh Johar case on decriminalization of Section 377 IPC

Role of USA judiciary 1. Marbury vs Madison (1803): foundation of judicial review, "due process of law" 2. Miranda vs State of Arizona: the Miranda warning, "I plead the 5th", and rights of defendants 3. 1st amendment cases: freedom on social media 4. 2nd amendment cases: "right to bear arms", etc.

Scope for judicial review wider in India Yes 1. India is the only democracy where the judiciary selects itself 2. In India: legislative, executive and lower court judgements can all be judicially reviewed; the scope is less wide in the USA, as the veto of the executive, some states having independent supreme courts, and the judiciary being selected by seniority, all narrow it 3. SC has expanded its powers of judicial review (eg: enquiring into facts for using Article 356; the Keisham Singh case, judicial review of the speaker's decision in anti-defection cases)

Thus, judiciary in India must exercise judicial restraint, to ensure separation of powers is maintained.