Analyze the controversial religious policies of Aurangzeb. Were his policies guided only by his puritanical mind?
Rajendra Bishnoi, AIR 161, 2023
The nature and impact of Aurangzeb's religious policies is a bone of contention between historians, who worked on Mughal empire. Different historians provided different view of his religious policies.
1. Anti-Hindu policies and led to decline of Mughal empire of Historians like Jadunath Sarkar and A.L. Srivastava termed Aurangzeb's policies such as imposition of Jaziya tax, abolition of Jharokha darshan, Tuledan etc. as Anti-Hindu. 2. To please muslim nobility => Some Historians like Sunil Kumar, Shireen Moosvi etc, termed his religious policies as a way to keep muslim nobility happy. 3. Economic necessity => Historians like Ashok Desai termed his measures like imposition of Jaziya, favours to muslim traders etc. as an economic necessity. 4. To gain support of regional southern muslim rulers => Many historians argued that he followed strict religious policies to garner support of muslim population and their local rulers. 5. Based on social & political conditions - Historians like Satish Chandra and Bhimsen critically analysed the religious policy of Aurangzeb and commented that most of his steps were need of the hour to strengthen mughal empire and economic necessity.
Critical evaluation
Minor steps like abolition of Tuledan, Jharokha darshan, few destruction of temples didn't impact Hindus as such, other measures like favours to muslim fredent were to bring them out of poverty. He was a strict follower of Sharia law. His measures were not Anti-Hindu, as many Rajputs were provided high Mansabs and Jagirs during his reign. He didn't force any religious conversion.
To term religious policy of Aurangzeb as guided by his puritanical mind, would be incorrect. Although there is no doubt that adhered to muslim traditions and was not liberal and tolerant like Akbar. Yet He ruled over a large empire successfully.