Q.4 (b) Critically examine the various views regarding the role of iron technology in ushering Second Urbanisation in Ancient India. [15 Marks]
Nidhin R H, AIR 699, 2025
Second urbanisation refers to the period post 6th centy BC when urban centres began popping up again in North India 1500 years (appron.) post Indus valley urbanisation owing to the agricultural surplus and establishment of long distance trade.
[a sketch map captioned "fig: second urbanisation core area"]
Role of Iron technology
Second urbanisation of India definitely happened in Iron age. But, how far presence of Iron aided urbanisation is widely debated.
View I Likes of R S Sharma claims Iron technology as single most important factor that drove revolution - Ability to clear forests - Iron tipped ploygh enabled deeper tilling and productivity - Better quality weapons for hunting and warfare aided chiefs to extend control, which led to rise of capitals towns.
All this led to surplus production and diversifications of crafts which led to trade linkages.
View II -> May historians criticize this view on basis of evidence 1. Fire could be used to clear forests 2. Even till medieval period, Gangetic plains were highly forested. 3. Iron technology was not well developed. It was restricted to warfare. Limited evidence of Iron ploughshare shows people still relied on wooden ones. 4. Iron mines of Bihar remained untapped showing limited penetration.
- Thus, technology though can be a game changer in ushering development, its role in history has to be analysed based on wider evidence. Iron did play a role in bringing second urbanisation. But, it should not be over emphasised.