'Genome editing holds immense potential for crop improvement, but it also raises ethical and safety concerns'. How far do the new guidelines for the safety assessment of genome-edited plants in India, ensure the safety of genetically modified crops?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
There has been a lot of progress in genome editing recently, with multiple technologies such as ZFN, CRISPR-Cas9, TALENs, etc.
Potential for crop improvements - Disease resistance (eg. rice resistant to bacterial blight) - Nutritional enhancement (eg. golden rice, vitamin A via beta-carotene) - Pest resilience (eg. Bt cotton) - Improved yields - Environmental tolerance (eg. GM rubber trials ongoing in Assam) - Herbicide tolerance (eg. HT-Bt cotton) - Cheaper feed for livestock, improving farmer margins (eg. GM soya, import allowed recently) - Climate resilience - Shelf life enhancement (eg. GM tomato)
Ethical/safety concerns 1. Impact on biodiversity, which is usually only expressed after a few generations. 2. Impact on human health. 3. "Off-target mutations." 4. Creation of pest resistance, i.e. pesticide-resistant pests, or "super bugs." 5. Terminator gene technology, leading to rising dependence of farmers on companies. 6. Ethical concerns: where to draw the line? If it is okay to make a GM crop for pest resistance, is it also okay to make GM crops just to change colour/texture? 7. Inequity in access: haves v/s have-nots.
New guidelines, and how they ensure safety 1. Applicable equally to the public and private sector, giving comprehensive coverage to ensure safety. 2. Exemptions for researchers and R&D from GEAC permission, allowing faster analysis of impact, greater democratization of research, and transparency. 3. Genome recovery guidelines for "off-target mutations," ensuring these mutations can't adversely affect human/environmental health. 4. Requirement of selection markers in GM-edited crops, i.e. transparency about whether a crop is GM or not, for more effective field trials. 5. Clear Standard Operating Procedures to be followed, with penalties for non-compliance, giving regulatory clarity.
The new guidelines are in line with global standards, and also with the Cartagena Protocol to the UNCBD (on the safe handling of Living Modified Organisms). India should focus on climate resilience in agriculture, with particular concern for biological diversity.