Topper Copies

Q.3 (b) Did ancient India have any interest in preserving the memory of the past? Critically Discuss. [15 Marks]

Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023

Many historians have argued the lack of sense of time and historiography due to complex nature and inherant issues in analysing the ancient literatures.

Issues in analysing ancient literatures

1. Predominantly religious character - there is an almost dearth of secular texts 2. Normative natures presenting view of ideal society according to authors - Eg.) Dharmashastras 'prohibit Varna exogamy but lay down rules for 'amuloma' marriages 3. Mixing of facts, events with myths, allegory and hyperbole 4. Complex and mind boggling conception of time. Eg → Time periods in Puranas (Yuga, Kalpa) 5. frequent additions, removals and modifications in old text to suit the contemporary context - (Eg) Didductive portion of Mahabharata were added in the later centuries

However, completely discarding ancient texts as certain sections represents an attempt to preserve memory of pasts - 1. Puranas gives the detailed genealogies of various dynasties -> Haryanka, Nandas, Maurayas, Andhras etc. 2. Ashokan inscriptions - Rock edict 13 describes ashoka's experience in the aftermath of Kalinga battle 3. Royal prashastis (Panegyric) - Allahabad inscriptions gives conquest of Samudragupta Similarly Aihole and Nasik inscriptions give details of Pulakeshin II and Gautamiputra Satakarni 4. Ancient Sangam texts - provide a glimpse of ancient Tamilakam society, economy - Puram poems - by bards were aimed at memorializing the achievements of their patron kings in war

Thus, the oriental views of ancient past and historiography should be changed in the presence of mounting evidence depicting an active tradition of record and book keeping and inscriptions in ancient India.