Q.2 (c) Discuss the social & economic factors for the rise of Buddhism. How far was it influenced by Upanisadic thought? [20 Marks]
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
The emergence of Shramanic religion in the 6th century BCE is often attributed to the complex socio-politico-economical milieu present in the north Indic at that time.
factors behind rise of Buddhism
Social factors
1. a) Opposition to brahmanical domination by kshatriyas - It was an attempt by kshatriya to accord themselves superior position in society - Kshatriya considered superior Varna in both Buddhism and Jainism 2. b) Social reform movement - aimed at alleviating conditions of people from lower classes - Women and shudra ⇒ allowed to join Buddist Samgha - Buddhism considered sacrifices as meaningless - Refused to accord divine sanction to Varnas — as in Brahmanism - Monks were advised to accept food from anyone including shudras
Economic factors
1. a) Supported by rich merchants (Setthis) - As brahmanism condemned usury - an attempt by merchants to gain upward mobility in the society - Setthis shown in buddhist texts in good light 2. b) Supported by peasants - Large scale animal sacrifices led to scarcity of cattle - It adversely impacted agriculture which was dependent on draught animals - Emphasis on Ahimsa and rejection of sacrifices attracted farmers 3. c) Disillusionment of many people with rising materialism - Wanted to go back to the vedic age devoid of greed, theft etc. - Buddhism provided an alternative and simple way of life for them
Upanishadic underpinnings of Buddhism
1. Less focus on ritual and sacrifices - a) Buddhist texts repeated downplayed the importance of sacrifices in worshipping - b) Chandogya upanishad - also mentions that by performing sacrifices one can only lead to world of forefathers but by gaining jnan one leads to world of god 2. Importances of knowledge - a) The goal of upanishadic ideology is cultivation of jnan (knowledge) which can lead to liberation (moksha) - b) Similarly, buddhism talks about Brahmana as an enlightened person (and not by performing sacrifice) - c) The goal of Buddhism is Nibbanna (enlightenment) and becoming free of worldly desires
However there were significant differences between the two ideologies — 1. Upanishad never rejected sacrifices as buddism 2. Upanishads believe in atman (soul) as opposed to buddhism 3. Upanishads held and strengthened the 4-fold Varna classification opposed to Buddhism
Thus although there were certain similarities significant differences existed in basic concepts between the two ideologies.