While AFSPA has been criticised for promoting excesses by the security forces, its profound utility to upkeep the security situation cannot be overstated. Comment.
Akansh Dhull, AIR 3, 2025
Armed Forces Special Power Act, 1958 provides exemplary powers to armed forces for search and seizure and even to shoot in disturbed areas. While the Nagaland operation caused public resentment, a recent report says that the Army is finding it difficult to ensure peace in Manipur due to removal of AFSPA
Criticised for Promoting Excesses
1. Human rights violations - Firing on unarmed civilians - Violence against women - Botched up operations (Eg Mon incident) 2. Impunity to operate - Right to open fire 3. Federal excesses - Law and order is a state list subject and it undermines the State's role.
Thus committees like Jeevan Reddy and the 2nd ARC have asked for its removal
Profound Utility in Security Situation
1. AFSPA is a measure of last resort, so deployment only means that normal public order has failed 2. Counter insurgency challenges (Eg North East) 3. Morale of the force is upheld; a morale hazard curbs operational efficiency 4. Required as security conflicts have cross border linkage [a rough map of India showing cross-border links to Pakistan via Kashmir and to China and Myanmar via the North East]
Thus a national security dimension is involved.
5. Past track record of swift action (Utilitarian - Reduce civilian casualty)
AFSPA's application should be gradually withdrawn but meanwhile safeguards should be added to increase accountability