Q.4 (c) Analyse different views regarding rise of Varna system in ancient India. [15 Marks]
Rajendra Bishnoi, AIR 161, 2023
A society based on Varna system is divided into 4 parts i.e. Brahmans, Kshatriyas, Vaishyas and shudras. Even modern Indian society follows this system, but its root go back to early vedic age.
1. In early vedic age there were basically 3 varnas i.e. Brahmans, Kshatriyas, and Vaishyas. Rigidity was not there, as people can change their Varna according to their profession. Rig vedic sources didn't put much emphasize on it. 2. In later vedic age, 4 varna concept became clear, 4th being the shudras, but here also people can move from one varna to other. Even in one family members can have different profession. A Rig vedic hymn says, "I am a poet, my father is a physician and my mother grinds corn, yet we live in a same family but earn income from different sources" This shows that rigidity was still not high in later vedic age. 3. During Mauryan empire and post Mauryan period was dominated by Buddhism and Jainism, so Varna system was not at a central stage. 4. foreign invasions and revival of Brahmanism in 2-3rd CE along with decline of heterogenous religion sect led to rigid varna system, Brahmans put responsibility on king to maintain social order to continue Varna system. Hiuen Tsang mentioned that when shudras came into cities of higher varnes they came by beating sound so that other people get aware about them. They lived separately and led separate profession. 5. During Gupta times and after that Varna system became birth based. If you are born in Shudra family, you are a Shudra, not based on profession.
later on with feudalism and more decline of Jainism and Buddhism, led to rise of Varna system in India's which in a way still prevelent. Varna system was not developed in a single day, it was a large process which took centuries to settle.