Topper Copies

Q.4 (b) "On circumstantial evidence Indra stands accused." Discuss the given statement in the context of the decline of Harappan Civilisation. [15 Marks]

Rajendra Bishnoi, AIR 161, 2023

Mature Harappan phase is considered between 2600 BCE to 1900 BCE. There are lot of theories about the sudden decline of Harappan civilization. One of the earliest popular theory is that Aryan invasion led to the decline of Harappan civilization.

Historians like Mortimer wheeler, and Stuart Piggott argued that Aryans led by Indra (Purandre) attacked the Harappan cities which led to their decline. In evidence they put that 37 skeletons together is found at Mohenjodaro which indicates of war and mass killing. This forced people to move out and most were killed so civilization declined.

They also mentioned Rigvedic sources which mention Indra being a large catapult and considered as a destroyer of civilization in Rig vedic and Aryan people. This Indra may led to believe them that Indra may have destroyed because he was capable to do it and also archaeological evidences are found as well.

But upon critical analysis, it was found that all 37 skeletons belonged to different - different period, they just were at same palace but timing was different.

Also, Aryans migrated to Iranian Subcentinent around 1500-1600 BCE but Harappan civilization declined in 18-19th BCE.

Theory of climate change put forward by Fair Servis and Deley is the most accepted theory in present day. This explain that Harappan civilization decline due to climate change and not of Aryan invasion.

So Indra is free from occupations in spite of some of decline of Harappe archaeological evidence.