Evaluating the theory of kingship of the Sultanate, discuss the deviations seen in the reigns of different Sultans.
Nidhin R H, AIR 699, 2025
Delhi Sultanate was established with military might under Turkish Theory of kingship. But, over time, theory of kingship evolved under various Sultans.
Sultanate theory of kingship
A. General features
1. Military character. - Delhi Sultanate was established on basis of superior military strength. eg: Military nobles in administrative role under Qutbuddin Aibak This continued later as well. eg: Malik Kafur rising to prominence as military leader and King maker 2. Racial theory of kingship There was a prevalent belief that only high-borns were meant to rule. Khalji revolution challenged this. eg: Barani says everyone was awestruck by low-born Khaljis occupying throne. But, Ibn Battuta testifies that racial character continued to hold prominence. 3. King as representative of Caliph - Islamic kingship - Quest for legitimacy of rule of Iltutmish ended in him getting letter of investiture in 1229. This secured throne for his successors. - Concept of Zil-i ilahi (shadow of god on earth - the king). Only such a king could claim legitimacy as per Balban. However, later, Alauddin Khalji denounces Islamic kingship. Later, only under Firuz Tughlaq did sharia and role of ulema came back strongly. 4. Benevolent and just kingship Early elements of same can be found in Razia's attempts like building schools and giving even handed justice. Balban's blood & iron policy involved ideal of justice as well. Though benevolence was not given importance, he told his son Bughra Khan to tax only moderately. Benevolent kingship got boost under Jalaluddin Khalji - kingship should be in the interest of governed. Alauddin Khalji, later reverted to strong policy & similar to Balban's. B/b, benevolence returned Sultanate via Firuz Tughlaq eg: Diwan-i khyrat for welfare
B. Oriental despotism - close to what Marxist historians proposed
From era of Iltumish, there was attempt to build a despotic state, which culminated in Balban's state. eg: Sijda & Paibos by Balban in court was symbol of his autocracy. Under Alauddin and Muhammad Tughlaq, state got centralised and despotism reached apex eg: Alauddin's measures to crush nobility and Muhammad's attempt to transfer capital despite oppositions.
Thus, in conclusion, the nature of kingship was constantly getting experimented and kings chose their policies based on their personal beliefs and exigencies of time.