Topper Copies

Q.4 (a) Do you agree with the view that ancient Indians did not have sense of historiography? Explain with the help of examples. [20 Marks]

Rajendra Bishnoi, AIR 161, 2023

Colonial historians like F. Max Mueller, Jones, V. Gordon Childe put forward the theory that Ancient Indians did not have sense of historiography. They don't know how to rule or keep their records. Colonial historians put this theory on the evidences like Ancient Indians have no written chronological sources about themselves, and they were unaware about history.

Colonial historians put this theory forward to legitimatize their colonial rule and reiterate their point that they are here to civilize the native people. Even Macaulay said, "one shelf of British library is more valuable and informative than the whole ancient Indian historical writings"

To counter this colonial notion and to generate self esteem in Indians, nationalist Historians like Rajendra lal, RG Bhandarkar, KAN Shastri, AD Pusalkar, Lala Lajpat Rai etc countered this colonialist theory by giving examples of Arthashastra of Chankya, literary vedic sources, Bana's Harshcharita and Kalhana's Rajtarangini etc.

But both the interpretation are not completely true as they proclaimed respectively.

According to me, As R.G. Collingwood argued in his book "what is history?" that the different civilizations and settlements have different styles of history keeping. So Ancient Indian

- People preferred oral traditions or such as Itihas- Purana literary tradition. Romila Thapar argues that it will be wrong to say that the ancient Indians had no sense of historiography by comparing with European method of history writing. She further argues that although Indians lack chronological history writing but literary sources like Vedas, Puranas, Secular literature, Sangam literature, Inscriptions are in plenty.

So, Before Kalhana's Rajtarangini Indians have no chronological historical writing to show but this can not termed as a lack of sense of historiography. Indians followed oral-bardic tradition to transfer knowledge from one generation to other. And even if they wrote, objects like leaves easily got destroyed in time. Indians had a sense of historiography although very different from present day European notions.