In the context of India, despite the presence of constitutional provisions, legal precedents, and international commitments that establish a robust foundation for a right to health, why has there been a lack of explicit legal recognition of this right?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
"Right to health" was declared as a part of right to life under Article 21 by the Supreme Court in the Bandhua Mukti Morcha case, 1988 — though for it to become justiciable, it has to be codified.
Barriers to explicit legal recognition 1. Constitutional barrier: health is in List 2 of the VII Schedule (i.e. the State List) 2. Fiscal barrier: inadequate fiscal capacity of union and states — expenditure on health by governments combined is ~2.8% of GDP (WHO recommended ~5% of GDP) 3. Infra barrier: many backward districts don't have the infra to implement a "right to health" (eg: lack of speciality hospitals, shortage of health care staff, etc) 4. Poor past experience with Right to Education: after implementation of RTE, learning outcomes have severely deteriorated (as evident from the Pratham ASER report) — some experts fear institutionalization of "right to health" would similarly deteriorate health outcomes 5. Doctors against "right to health" (eg: protests in Rajasthan against the Right to Health Bill)
Way forward: a step by step approach 1. Right to health insurance, as recommended by the Economic Survey 2. Upgrading all PHCs to HWCs, plus one medical college in each district 3. WHO recommended doctor-population ratio (1:1000) 4. A holistic approach to health, including geriatric care and lifestyle aids