Topper Copies

"With the best intentions, excellent ideas, but no balance or patience, no sense of proportion, Muhammad Tughluq was a transcendent failure". Elaborate.

Nidhin R H, AIR 699, 2025

Reign of Muhammad Bin Tughlaq (1324-51) had been one of controversies. The lives of Ibn Battuta calls him an "ill - starred idealist" and Barani criticises him for his projects. But, accounts of Barani shows that his reign started with hope of a golden future under a stable economy and learned ruler.

Muhammad Tughlaq as a transcendent failure

1. Best intentions

He was well learned and literate person and genuinely worked to do good for the kingdom. eg: Appointing officers based on merit He hoped for best outcomes via his experiments. eg: Token currency to address shortage of silver (J L Mehta)

2. Excellent ideas

His ideas were far beyond his time

- Idea of token currency was similar to modern fiat currency. Likes of Kublai khan had already experimented with it successfully. - Capital change to Daulatabad. As empire grew, he wanted to have a central capital (Ferishta). He also considered Delhi as too close to North western boundary to defend. - Bold plan to invade Khorasan, ending Mongol menace.

3. But, no balance or portience

His policies were implemented in haste or without properly thinking thngh.

eg: Historians point out that some rebles suggested Ujjain as a much better location for capital.

4. No sense of proportions

He never did a pros. and cons. analysis of his policies. or brought out proportionate checks and balances.

- Take case of token currency - No check measures brought on to prevent counterfeiting - No agreement with foreign governments for trade exchge.

- Thus, one cannot blame him for his intentions or ideas, but his failures was Transcendental as many later historians pointed out, this began process of disintegration of empire. 16 major rebellions propped up since 1335 and within half century, his empire shrunk to only around deab.

Was he a failure in reality?

One cannot judge him based on contemporary histories alone.

1. Likes of Barani were biased being a noble (eg: criticising merit-based appointment). He focuses only on failure of Muhammed. 2. Ibn Battuta in 1334 notes economy as prosperous - no trace of token currency experiment or capital chge. 3. Circumstances also played a role - Khurasan expedition did not materialise as situation in Central Asia chyed. eg: Tamarshirin (his ally) deposed. 4. Corruption of administration led to higher tax incidence, causing distress and rebellions

Thus, his failures where not his alone. He was bold enogh to admit his failures and move along. Further, it is safe to conclude that he was far beyond his time.