"Sufis and medieval mystic saints failed to modify either the religious ideas and practices or the outward structure of Islamic/Hindu societies to any appreciable extent." Comment for/against.
Simran, AIR 66, 2024
Medieval Indian history witnessed the socio-cultural phenomenon of Bhakti-Sufi movement aiming at social transformation but failing at several points.
Mystic saints failed to modify religious ideas
1. lacked systematic theology :- According to David Lorenzo, Bhakti movement did not have systematic approach to religion due to which it failed to have lasting impact. 2. Political alofness :- Connection with political institutions provides great push to one's ideas. - Sufis such as Chisti's and several Bhakti saints such as Kabir, Guru Nanak refused to form any such association. 3. Continued Caste discrimination Primarily against caste yet these saints failed to directly challenge it. - Chaitanya Mahaprabhu allowed his upper caste followers to maintain caste purity. - Caste system continued to prevail. - Even in Sikhism - Ramgarhia Sikhs. 4. Failure on front of gender Several women saints such as Akka Mahadevi, Lalded, Bainabai, etc. created waves but remained to limited extent. - A.K. Ramanuj notes that large-scale women remained confined to households. 5. Gradual acceptance of orthodoxy Vaishnav Bhakti largely remained in Brahmanic fold. - Shankradeva condemned weakening of Varnashram Dharma. - Chisti sufis (Gesu Daraz) accepted Orthodox ulemas.
Mystic saints succeeded in creating change
1. Voice to masses :- Bhakti-Sufi movement gave voice to large section of lower caste, vulnerable groups. - Chisti Khangahs were open for Shudras. - Varkari sect represented lower caste. 2. Promotion of vernacular :- Dialects and local languages chosen by saints enabled masses to attain religious awareness. 3. Challenge to patriarchy :- Ramanuj highlighted the success of women saints in challenging status quo through nakedness and resistance. 4. Caste challenged :- To some extent, saints like Kabir, Nanak, etc. challenged institution of caste and ritualisation.
According to D.N. Jha, these were not just religious reform movement but social and cultural phenomenon promoting egalitarianism