Q.2 (a) Critically examine different views related to the rise of Marathas as a major power in Deccan towards the middle of the 17th century?
Rajendra Bishnoi, AIR 161, 2023
Rise of Marathe in Deccan towards the middle of the 17th century was attributed to several reasons. Different historians have put forward different theories about the rise of Marathe power:
1. Hindu reaction against Aurangzeb's policies. Historians like Jadunath Sarkar and A.L. Srivastava termed rise of Marathe as a Hindu response to orthodox policies of Aurangzeb. - This view is not true because Marathe led many Muslim soldiers and they also attacked Hindu states. 2. National movement for independence. - Historians like M G Ranade and R G Bhandarkar termed Marathe rise as Indian national movement. - This view also does not hold ground because there was nothing like Indian state in 17th C. 3. Ability of powerful kings like Shahji, Shivaji and Sambhaji. Many Historians like Shireen Moosvi termed rise of Marathe to capable rulers. 4. Gureilla warfare and its success. - Many Historians termed rise of Marathe to Gureilla warfare method, which they were mester of. - This also defined the loss in 1761. 5. social - political and geographical factors. Historians like Satish chandra and Bhimsen termed rise of Marathe - to social and political conditions. social - conditions of poverty with youth forced them to form army and fought wars. Harsh geography of Vidarbha and Marathwada region also a reason of solid foundation.
No single factors can define the rise of marathe power. Factors like social, political and geographical condition is the most acceptable theory in modern day history fraternity.