Topper Copies

Highlight the key differences in the scope of Freedom of speech and expression as provided under Parliamentary privileges vis a vis Fundamental rights. Why is it necessary to maintain a balance between parliamentary privilege and fundamental rights?

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

Freedom of speech and expression and Parliamentary privileges are both found in the constitution, in Article 19(1)(a) and Article 105 (and 194) respectively.

Differences

| Ground of difference | Freedom of speech | Privileges | |---|---|---| | Applicable on whom? | Citizens | Legislators (MPs/MLAs) | | Applicable where? | Everywhere in India | In legislature only | | Reasonable restrictions | Under Article 19(2): sovereignty, integrity, etc | Uncodified, no explicit restrictions | | Purpose | Achieving liberty, allowing citizens to express themselves, media freedom | Allow legislators to speak freely, protect law makers from interference in discharge of their democratic duty | | Enforcing authority | Writs under Article 32/226 | Parliament itself |

Necessary to maintain a balance between the two 1. Parliament's right to exclude citizens from its proceedings/prevent people from talking about it → violation of freedom of speech of citizens 2. Similarly for secret/"in camera" proceedings 3. Uncodified nature is against principles of rule of law, hence judicial privileges have been codified 4. Misused for corruption (eg: Narsimha Rao vs CBI case) → hence the NCRWC recommended an amendment to Article 105 to explicitly exclude corruption from its ambit 5. Lack of judicial review (eg: Keshav Singh case) → judiciary should ideally have the power of judicial review

Way forward: rational use, codification of parliamentary privileges, and explicitly excluding corruption.