How did early Indian historical tradition, as reflected in Itihasa-Purana, emerge? What are the distinctive features of this genre? [20 Marks]
Simran, AIR 66, 2024
Indian historical traditions were often ridiculed by Western historians such as [?] Huntery, H.H. Wilson, etc. However, recent studies by Romila Thapar, Pathak have revealed the concept of 'Embedded histories'.
Indian historical traditions in Itihasa-Purana
Romila Thapar in her work on Early Historical traditions noticed that Indian sense of history differed from current ideas on history writing. - Ancient Indian writers would merge history with mythology. (Ex) → Epics of Mahabharata and Ramayana. - The history would become 'embedded' in the narrative and need to be extracted and understood. Ex.-> Mahabharata's focus on clan war indicate existence of large kingdoms, dispute on inheritance of throne, etc. - Beginning with bardic traditions, where soldiers accompanying kings in war or charioteers would compose songs for glorification of kings. - With time these stories came to be recorded in literary forms resulting in stutis, narratives, puranas, etc. - As social complexities increased, new additions were made to these historical tradition. Ex The didactic part in Mahabharata was added much later to address societal moral values.
Distinctive features of the genre
1. Bardic traditions. These were oral traditions. However Thapar notes that element of chronological sequence of kings could be noticed. 2. Stutis Thapar highlights that the record of gift giving, indirectly recorded details of activities- 3. Gatha - Narasamis According to Pathak, the act of eulogising contemporary kings in gathas recorded history. 4. Itihasa -purana traditions It mainly includes Epics of Ramayana and Mahabharata. - It literally means 'Thus it was' hence recording the happening of the time.
[?] Mahabharata This epic records the struggle for power between clans of Kaurava and Pandava. - Descriptions about Kuru and Panchal empire. - Mention of contemporary traditions of marriage. (Ex) Polyandry by Draupadi.
(B) Ramayana Story of lord Rama leaving his kingdom to wander in forests. - Description of geography, polity and culture. - Signifies emergence of large kingdoms. - Use of plough (hal) by kings mentioned.
- Puranas Records geneological history of various dynastics, along with secular information like geography, artistic development, etc.
Due to these sources being 'embedded' the task of reading them become difficult but this does not show lack of historical sense in ancient Indians. They knew both linear and cyclical times.