The urban character of the Harappan Civilization was a result of neither of any outside influence nor a sudden act but a gradual evolution of regional socio-economic factors. Comment. [15 Marks]
Simran, AIR 66, 2024
There has been intense debate on the nature of urbanisation of Harappan Civilisation. Though the civilisation depicted all the features of Gordon Childe's requirements for urbanisation, historians question the origin of these features.
Harappan civilisation — result of outside influence
British historians such as M. Wheeler and others argue that Mesopotamian influence lead to Harappan civilisation. - There may not be diffusion of people but diffusion of ideas.
However, this theory is refuted.
Harappan Civilisation as a result of Sudden act
It points towards Aryan invasion which led to establishment of civilisation. - However there is no evidence to match chronology of both events
- Harappans were already residing in North Western subcontinent. - Aryans were identified with Painted Grey Ware Culture which came much after Harappans. - Harappan civilisation was in bronze-age, while Aryans are associated with iron-age.
Harappan Civilisation as gradual evolution
1. Existing agrarian societies :- Region of Harappan civilisation was the same where 1st evidences of agriculture emerged. (Ex) Mehrgarh. 2. Early Harappan cultures Sites such as Kot Diji, Amri, Mundigak, Daab Saadat; etc display pre-harappan characteristics in terms of pottery, trade links, agrarian development. 3. Archaeological studies studied the growth of Sothi Pottery and found similarities with later Harappan pottery. 4. Geographical factors Gradual extension of agriculture around fertile regions around Indus led to growth of communities who began specialisation in crafts.
Harappan civilisation emerged and prospered due to lost of factors. However, mere categorisation as outside influenced or sudden act do no justice to its grandeur.