Topper Copies

Recognizing the pivotal role of urbanization as a driver of national economic growth, the Fifteenth Finance Commission has suggested major reforms for Urban Local Bodies. Evaluate the recommendations put forward by the Fifteenth Finance Commission in promoting and revitalizing ULBs in India.

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

The 15th Finance Commission (15th FC) has granted Rs 1.5 lakh cr to ULBs (Urban Local Bodies), an increase of 78% from the 14th FC — the highest ever, since the 74th Amendment.

Alongside this high devolution, the 15th FC has also given major reforms:

1. Mandatory upload of unaudited as well as audited accounts → will lead to more transparency, allow effective scrutiny by CAG and the public, and prevent scams and corruption 2. Notification and updation of the floor rate on property tax → to remove the loophole in property tax collection caused by the politician-mafia-real estate nexus; the Economic Survey has observed that ULBs in India collect only 5-20% of potential property tax due to this nexus 3. Increase property tax collection annually, to be continuously eligible for grants (eg: Nagpur municipality was recently refused grants for not increasing property tax collection) → will enhance fiscal capacity of ULBs, since property tax:GDP in India is ~0.5% (whereas ~2-3% in Brazil, USA, etc), and per capita expenditure on urban infra is ~Rs 17 in India vis Rs ~116 in China 4. Classification into million-plus and less-than-million population cities, with 100% and 60% tied grants respectively (for solid waste management, air pollution and water supply) → will improve quality of life, empower slum populations, and reduce disease burden through cleaner air 5. Rs 38,000 cr of performance-linked grants → will improve competition among ULBs 6. Documentary records online → easy to raise funds via municipal bonds

Way forward: land pooling (Ahmedabad model), transit-oriented development (Budget 2022), vertical expansion, granular street planning (GIS), and a Model Tenancy Act to reduce disputes.