"The religious policies of Aurangzeb were controversial in nature and were guided by his puritanical mind." Critically analyse by giving proper examples.
Kaushik Mishra
Nationalist School of historians like Jadunath Sarkar are of the view that religious policies of Aurangzeb were guided by his puritan mindset.
Argument or Evidences given in favour are :-
- Aurangzeb banned religious festivals of Holi and Diwali - He even banned the processions by Shia Muslims on Nauroz as Aurangzeb was puritan Sunni Muslim - He reimposed 'jazia' tax on hindu population - He destroyed the temples like 'Kashi Vishwanath'
However another school of historians with scholars like Noorul Hassan have provided Counter arguments like :-
- Holi was banned due to excessive liquor consumption and law and order issues. Similarly Diwali was banned due to excessive fireworks or 'Atishbaazi' - Nouroz was banned as such procession could have caused clashes among Shia and Sunni communities hence to maintain peace - Reimposition of 'Jazia' was to maintain Sovereignity against Maratha Expansionism who imposed 'Chauth' and 'Sardeshmukhi' in Mughal territories. That's why it was not imposed since beginning of his rule but later on. - Kashi Vishwanath Temple was destructed due to facilitating Shiva ji's escape as a retaliatory measure.
However Marxist Historians like Prof. Irfan Habib and Athar Ali have divided Aurangzeb's policies as - Major Consequential and - Minor Inconsequential.
Minor inconsequential policies like - Banning the practice of Quranic Verses on Coins - to save disrepect - Ending the tradition of jharokha darshan etc. Started by Akbar had less impact.
Major Consequential Policies like - Differential Taxation on Traders Eg: Muslim 2.5%. Hindu - 5% - Deputation of only Muslims as Iqtadars in rich Ganga-Yamuna Doab Region - Aggressive policy against [?] Rajputs, Jats etc.
Lead to greater impact on Secular outlook Hence due to such differential views its a matter of debate but in any case acts like Temple demolishion cannot be justified as observed by Audrey Truschke.