Topper Copies

Discuss the key function of the Public Accounts Committee (PAC). What steps should be taken to revamp the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) in order to enhance its effectiveness as a true guardian of public funds?

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

Public Accounts Committee (PAC) is considered the most important parliamentary committee, on account of its duty to keep oversight over fiscal expenditure by the executive.

It has evolved through the years: starting in 1921, with only Lok Sabha members by the 1950s, the chairpersonship going to the ruling party by 1967, and to the opposition party by the 1960s-70s, when members were also increased to 22; by 2008 a 20-member JPC was recommended for the 2G scam.

Key functions of PAC 1. Parliamentary oversight of money granted to the executive, i.e. "legislative scrutiny of budgetary functions" 2. Examination of CAG reports — CAG acts as "friend, philosopher and guide" to PAC (eg: 2G spectrum case) 3. Examining accounts of different departments (eg: whether expenditures are under the right heads) 4. Looking into issues of over-utilization/under-utilization of money granted in demand for grants 5. Discover misuse/abuse, if any (eg: Commonwealth Games scam, Adarsh Housing Society scam) 6. Make recommendations for fiscal prudence

Reforms needed 1. Currently, the role of PAC is ex-post facto, in a more dynamic and rapidly changing environment → need for real time oversight (eg: on a quarterly basis) 2. Longer tenure (currently 1 year) → to allow members to develop expertise 3. Permanent research and secretarial support 4. Greater jurisdiction (eg: over PPP/infrastructure projects, as currently Rs 5 lakh crore of money is stuck in infra projects due to delays → duty of Parliament to look into it)

Way forward 1. A Fiscal Council — 360° oversight of budget — recommended by NK Singh 2. OR a Parliament Budget Office — as in USA, etc.