Topper Copies

Assess Abul Fazl as a historian of Mughal India.

Kritika Bhardwaj, AIR 370, 2023

Abul fazl- the author of celebrated works like Ain-i-Akbari and Akbarnama-was one of the nine jewels (navratna) of Akbar's court.

Abul fazl as Historian of Mughal India 1. Akbarnama provides a detailed historical narrative right from the beginning of Timur's family till the reign of Akbar.

2. Provides a concrete theory of Kingship - in which he argues that :

The two are joined by a SOCIAL CONTRACT. 3. Provides a secular interpretation of history. (e.g) not heavily influenced under Islamic narrative. 4. Provides valuable Statistical and economic details -> economic history. (e.g) with reference to tax rates, loans (taqvis), methods of revenue assessment (khet-batai, lang-batai), prices of commodities etc. 5. Presents an overall socio-cultural picture of the time -> (e.g) Social conditions, philosophy, material culture, technological status (e.g) metallurgy, weaponry etc.

Limitations of Abul Fazl : - Since he was writing as Court Chronicler, account is bound to be biased in favour of Akbar. (e.g) not mentioned the failure of karori experiment of Akbar. - Narrative from above - no focus on common masses like peasants or working classes. - Mixed with mythology (e.g. Akbar's ancestors descended from heaven.

Despite these shortcomings, Abul Fazl has definitely carved out a niche as one of the most credible historian of Mughal age due to his systematic study and organisation of facts.