Topper Copies

Examine the role of the Inter-state Council in promoting vertical (Centre-State) and horizontal (Inter-State) Intergovernmental cooperation and coordination.

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

Inter-State Council is a constitutional body under Article 263, with the following objectives: 1. Establish cordial relationships horizontally and vertically 2. Resolve interstate issues and conflicts through agreements 3. Create a strong support system 4. Provide a platform to all states and UTs for debate and discussion

Role of ISC in promoting vertical cooperation and coordination 1. Clarity with respect to scope of Article 256 → extent of admin powers of centre and state 2. Coordination in implementation of centrally sponsored schemes - Case study: ISC-2016 (11th meeting) — implementation plan for financial inclusion → Jan Dhan Yojana → banking touchpoint in 5 km radius 3. Cooperation and modernization of police — discussed in ISC-2016 (11th meeting): CCTNS, inter-operable criminal justice systems, info exchange 4. Resolution of disputes (eg: coal dispute over royalty on processed coal — coal mining states v/s centre, eg Jharkhand — resolved in ISC-2017, 12th meeting) 5. Consideration of Punchhi Commission recommendations

Role in horizontal collaboration and cooperation 1. Resolution of border disputes (eg: Jharkhand-WB border dispute resolved via ISC-2016 and 2017 meetings) 2. Resolution of cross-state electricity supply (eg: one nation one grid, and green energy corridor) 3. Inter-state trade and commerce 4. Inter-state river disputes; platform for discussion (eg: Cauvery river dispute) 5. Sharing and exchange of best practices 6. Support system

Way forward: only 12 meetings have been held since independence, of which 5 were in 1999-2004. More ISC meetings are needed, like during the tenure of PM Vajpayee, the only time the ISC was used effectively.