Topper Copies

"The Paris Peace Conference must stand in history a conspicuous failure. It was an overall failure of human intelligence and wisdom." Examine.

Kritika Bhardwaj, AIR 370, 2023

The Paris Peace Conference was an assembly of WWI victor powers to decide the terms of peace following Germany's surrender on 11th Nov 1918.

Paris Treaty as a failure

1. Extremely harsh treaty for Germany revealing its revengeful nature: - 1.1 German representative was not allowed to participate or even sit in the discussion. - 1.2 All the provisions were unilaterally decided by victor powers and forced down the throat of Germany. - 1.3 All the German colonies - including Alsace and Lorraine, coal-rich region of Saar were snatched from Germany and distributed among victor powers. - 1.4 The treaty was deliberately signed in Palace of Versailles (where unification of Germany was proclaimed 50 years ago). 2. The Treaty of Versailles failed to provide lasting peace to Europe. In fact, on the contrary, it led to widespread instability in Germany ⟶ giving rise to Nazism under Adolf Hitler (who wanted to avenge German humiliation) ⟶ eventually causing WWII (1939-45).

Paris Treaty as failure of Human Intelligence and Wisdom

1. Treaty was not only politically unstable, but also very impractical. While 70% of German industrial areas were given to newly created nations, a huge war indemnity (6,600 million pounds) was imposed on Germany as well. - In such a harsh term of treaty, expecting peace and stability was a huge error. "Germany suffered more during peace than war." 2. The high idealism (as reflected in Woodrow Wilson's '14 Points') was soon discarded after the WW1 and all the victor powers started pursuing their selfish interest. (e.g) Britain under Woodrow wilson did NOT want complete destruction for Germany as it was Britain's market On the other hand, Italy under G.B. Clemenceau wanted an aggressive approach towards Germany

Thus, this short-sighted approach of victor powers couldn't assure any tangible results.

"Treaty of Versailles was just another armistice for 20 years. It contained the Seeds of another war."