Q.3 (b) Critically examine the principal causes of the rise of Marathas in the 17th century.
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
The rise of marathas in the 17th century was a significant event in the Indian history, which was to dominate Indian affairs for the next 150 years.
1. Hindu reaction against Aurangzeb's narrow bigoted policies - As per J.N Sarkar, the puritanical policies of Aurangzeb was met with the a strong "Hindu reaction" in the form of Marathas. - Critique - Shivaji allied with muslim state (Bijapur)
2. Struggle of independence against foreigners - M.G.Rande argues that marathas fought against the foreign mughal rule. - Critique - Mughals rule for more than 100 years and cannot be claimed as foreigners.
3. Weakness of the mughal empire - Irfan Habib and Athar Ali has emphasized mughals weakness due to agrarian and jagirdari crisis as a cause of maratha rise. - Critique - Too much focus on mughals.
4. Regional aspiration - Andre Wink and Muzzafar Alam highlighted the strong regional tendencies in Punjab, Awadh and deccan in the wake of weak centre - Critique - Misses out on other socio-economic dimensions.
5. Socio economic movement - Satish Chandra argues that maratha movement was a movement of "upward mobility" of low class martha bargirs to powerful chiefs by invoking hindu and maratha pride.
6. Capable leadership of Shivaji Maharaj - Jadunath Sarkar lauds the excellent leadership of Shivaji and says him as the last great ruler the 'hindu race' has produced.
Thus, the story of maratha rise is a story of politico-economic and social rise of regional states - a dominant theme towards the end of Mughal empire