Q.1 (a) Critically examine the major observations of François Bernier about India.
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
Francois Bernier was a french physician who visited India in the 17th Century and is known for sharp critic of mughal polity, economy and society in his looks "The Travels in the Mogul India"
Major Observation
1. Absence of private property - Bernier argued that, there was not private property and everything belonged to crown - Critique - Various mughal charter talks of inheritable rights on land, also jagirdari was only assignment of revenue rights and not proprietory rights
2. Absence of middle class - Bernier says that there is no middle class and Indian are "unsegregated mass of impoverished masses" - The minority 'foreigner' rulers exploited the majority poor - Critic - a vast and thriving middle class was present - merchants, traders, civil servants, hakims, artisans etc.
3. Cities as "Camp towns": - Bernier surmises that the cities had no viable structure and owe their existence completely to the royal army - Critic - Major cities like Varanasi, ahemdabad thrived on trade, spirituality etc.
Thus, Bernier accounts are majorly meant for european audience. Nonetheless they continue to be important source of history