Topper Copies

"The court intrigues and the defiance of the provincial powers, both hastened the decline of the Mughals in the 18th century." Comment.

Simran, AIR 66, 2024

In 18th century, Mughals were witnessing decline in royal authority in political, economic and territorial arenas. Various historians have forwarded different interpretations for this phenomenon.

Court intrigues hastening Mughal decline

1. Inefficient nobility: Later Mughals saw rise and decline of not just emperors but also nobles who destabilised the polity. - Ex. Hassan brothers under Farrukh Siyar. 2. Weak rulers: Jadunath Sarkar argued that the successors of Aurengzeb were extremely inefficient and lacked character to sustain the empire. 3. Rise of successor states: Gradual breaking of empire into successor states began in early 18th century. - Ex. → Bengal under Murshid Quli Khan in 1718 and Awadh under Saadat Khan in 1724.

Defiance of provincial powers hastening Mughal decline

1. Defiance by Jagirdars: According to Satish Chandra, Mughal jagirdari system had stretched beyond its capacity. - Consequently, Jagirdars began revolting and creating independent areas on influence. 2. Rise of local dynasties: 18th century witnessed rise of vibrant economy and culture at local levels. - (Ex.) Muzaffar Alam described how Awadh maintained its influence in face of Mughal decline. 3. The Great Firm theory: Historian Karen Leonard argues that in 18th century local economic classes such as merchants gained immense powers. - These class supported regional rulers instead of Mughal emperor. 4. Culture of defiance: Chetan Singh argued that Mughal Empire was not fully centralised. - Defiance existed in peripherial areas earlier too. - (Ex) In Punjab, Jagirdars resisted transfers.

Other reasons for Mughal decline

1. Agrarian Crisis: Irfan Habib pointed that high revenue demands created resentment among rural masses. - Frequent revolts, example, jats, satnamis, etc. 2. Flawed land Revenue system: W.H. Moreland and Shirin Moosvi viewed that Mughal land revenue system created too much pressure on rural areas while empowered state officials.

Despite of this, Mughals had retained symbolic power. They had maintained army and huge artillery.

However, by 19th century, their existence became symbolic leading to decline of Mughals and rise of British.