"Though the Marathas were clever and brave individually, they lacked the corporate spirit which was essential for national independence." Elaborate with reasons.
Simran, AIR 66, 2024
In early eighteenth century, Marathas reached zenith of power in subcontinent. However, in later half of century, they were on the way to decline.
Marathas had individual bravery but lacked corporate spirit
1. Establishment of strong confederacies: Maratha confederacies such as Gaikwads, Holkars, Bhonsles were strong contenders for power. - However, they were fraught with mutual jealousies. 2. Lack of administrative vision: Even as Marathas become powerful by placing puppet ruler in Delhi, they did not evolve administrative structure in new territories. - (Ex.) -> Only Malwa, Gujarat and Khandesh had loose administrative setup. 3. Distanced their neighbours: In face of Afghan challenge, Marathas had no one by their side. - They previously fought with Jats, Rohillas and constantly raided neighbouring areas. 4. Lack of able leadership: After Balaji Baji Rao, Marathas suffered from death of a leader who could unite diverse confederacies - 5. Prioritised greed over stable economy: Marathas did not attempt to create sustainable means of economic resources in later half of 18th century. - Instead relied on raids.
However, there were other factors which weakened Maratha polity:-
1. Military incapacity: Marathas were expert in gureilla warfare. - They failed to tackle open ground war of Panipat in 1761. 2. Rise of English East India Company: Using its shrewd diplomacy and advanced weaponary EIC posed grave challenge to Marathas. 3. Consequently, various challenges made it difficult for Marathas to sustain the Empire, leading to its end after third Anglo-Maratha war.