"Interstate border disputes, if not promptly and impartially settled, can transform into persistent issues that impede development and generate friction". Highlighting the constitutional and legal framework to resolve interstate disputes, explain why Independent India has failed to resolve inter-state border disputes.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
Indian federalism is based on the principle of cooperative federalism, and it is constitutional duty of Union and States to resolve differences amicably.
Constitutional and legal framework for inter-state disputes
Constitutional 1. Article 3: power to Union govt to amend boundaries 2. Article 263: Inter-State Council — platform for cordial relationships, to resolve issues 3. Article 131: SC's original jurisdiction over centre-state disputes 4. Article 262: river disputes — outside jurisdiction of SC, etc.
Legal 1. Zonal Councils Act 1956, etc 2. Inter State River Disputes Act, River Boards Act, etc
However, these frameworks have not been successful w.r.t border disputes as:
1. Infrequent meeting/laziness of the Inter State Council and Zonal Councils 2. Colonial legacy/historical reasons - linguistic reorganisation was "easier said than done" - has led to lingering issues such as (Belagavi, MH + KN border) etc - lack of clarity over demarcation of area in North East (eg: extent of Lushai Hills district → Mizoram-Assam border dispute) 3. Shifting cultivation, nomadic tribes → demand for new area (eg: Nagalim, Kukiland demands) 4. High public emotion involved → difficult to resolve amicably (eg: water disputes, Kaveri: KN-TN) 5. Lack of political will: political parties putting undue focus on unresolved borders (eg: Belagavi/Belgaon)
However, if coordination is there, issues can be resolved: as evident from resolution of the Jharkhand-WB (2016) border dispute in the Zonal Council and Inter State Council.