Q.2 (b) "Harsha combined in himself the piety of Ashoka and the valour of Samudragupta." Discuss this statement.
Rajendra Bishnoi, AIR 161, 2023
Harsha ruled over the most of the Northern India from about 610 AD to 645 AD. He shifted his seat of power from Thanesar to Kannauj and ruled from there. Two most important source of Harsha period are Banabhat's Harshcharita and Hiuen Tsang's Si-yu-ki.
Piety of Ashoka in Harsha Ashoka's Dhamma policy was almost a crux of all religions. According to Romila Thapar, he used Dhamma even for political aggrandizement. Ashoka was a follower of Buddhism and took part in welfare activities. He spread his message all over the Indian subcontinent and gave up on war after Kalinga's war. Harsha was a follower of Mahayana Buddhism. His extent was very limited in compare to Ashoka. He also held Buddhist council like Ashoka. But he never gave up war.
Harsha had similarity with Ashoka But at minuscule level Ashoka was bit different even in pity from Harsha.
As valour of Samudragupta Harsha called himself as " Sakale uttarapathe" (king of whole north) which is not true in complete sense. According to R.C. Majumdar many parts were outside Harsha rule.
Harsha was a brave ruler and he took long journey for war. But he lost to Pulakesin II, Acording to Aihole inscription. Samudragupta had ruled over a very large part of Indian -Subcontinent as compared to Harsha.
Samudragupta was never beaten in war unlike Harsha. Samudragupta left behind a rich legacy for Gupta period which was not the case for Harsha.
In a way, although with certain limitations, Harsha was an impressive and brave ruler but terming him of and combination of piety of Ashoka and valour of Samudragupta will be injustice to history