Discuss the nature of the French Revolution in the light of the views of historians.
Kritika Bhardwaj, AIR 370, 2023
French revolution (1789-99) turned out as a significant milestone in the history of not only Europe, but the entire world - as with this revolution - a wave of Republicanism and Liberty flew across Europe - threatening monarchies far and wide.
Nature of french Revolution
1. Intellectual Revolution: Early historians of french revolution like Alexis De Tocqueville, Hippolyte Taine, Daniel Mornet etc. described the revolution as being originated by french intellectuals and 'philosophe.' They argued that these 'men of letters' imparted revolutionary ideas to the french revolution (e.g) Voltaire's Ideas of Enlightenment, Rousseau's (Social Contract) theory, Montesquieu's Spirit of Laws. Later, even historian françois furet supported this view. 2. Social Revolution - Many historians (notably Marxist historians) argue that French Revolution was a struggle to overthrow feudalism (ancien regime) and establish capitalism. Thus, it was a bourgeoisie revolution by rising capitalist and middle class: (e.g) Third Estate coming together and convening the Estate General, right to property Notable historians of this school are Alphonso Aulard, Albert Mathiez; Georges Lefebre. 3. Mass Revolution - every group participated in the revolution - turning it from a class to a mass upheaval. 1. Middle class - arguing for equal political and economic rights (e.g) Suffrage, public offices based on merit, property rights 2. Peasants - They had to pay high taxes under the ancient regime, perform forced labour (corvée) for feudal lords. Thus, they were at the forefront of the revolution. 3. Sans-cullottes revolution was also a part of this french revolution as they reflected defiance against authority. They were common people of the lower classes who got radicalised (eg. 'Conspiracy of Equals') 4. Women: → From the very beginning, women participated in the revolutionary uprisings. (e.g) Women's march against high bread prices in October 1789 ushered in the revolution. - Soap riots were pioneered by women. - Political rights were demanded. (e.g) Olympe de Gouges, Madame Tallien 4. Cultural Origins: Some historians like Roger Chartier showed that french revolution was made possible due to an emerging public cultural sphere - books, meetings, societies, cafes, print culture and literature. 5. Trans-Atlantic Revolution: Some historians argue that French Revolution was not an isolated revolution, but a part of a larger phenomenon called Trans-Atlantic revolution. (e.g) beginning from America, France, Geneva, Netherlands, Italy etc.
Thus, rather than being just a political overthrow of french monarchy, french Revolution was a composite movement containing Socio-economic, cultural and philosophical strands.