Topper Copies

"With the best intentions, excellent ideas, but no balance or patience, no sense of proportion, Muhammad Tughluq was a transcendent failure". Elaborate.

Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023

Muhammad Bin Tughluq (MBT) embarked on a series of socio-economic and political reforms which despite good intentions failed miserably or remained inconclusive.

Reforms and results of MBT

1. Capital Shifting from Delhi to Daulatabad - a. started in 1328, daulatabad was made the 2nd capital of sultanate. - b. Intention - Daulatabad lay at the centre of empire - better management. - familiarity of terrain and atmosphere - c. Result - led to huge resentment in the population of Delhi. - also large scale burden on state exchequer - Death of many while travelling in hot summer months - Law and order situation in delhi deteriorated - d. Finally, due to rebellion and loss of territory capital reshifted to Delhi. 2. Token currency - a. MBT issued coins of copper and brass freely exchangeable with gold and silver. - b. Intention - to tide over scarcity of silver. - To hire a large army at low cost. - Expansion of money economy and trade - c. Result - Rampant Counterfeiting of currency - Barani - "house of every hindu became a mint". - huge confusion among common people - As per Satish Chandra, the surplus coins reduced its value to nothingness. - d. Finally, the sultan withdrew the coins and exchanged it with gold and silver. 3. Khurasan expedition - a. MBT hired a large corp of army and awarded them iqtas. - b. However, Barani says that no effort was taken to asses swordsmanship of soldiers or quality of horses. - c. Intention — Was to lead an expedition to Khurasan to get rid of Mongol menace. - d. Result — finally due to lack of terrain knowledge, the army was disbanded after an year. 4. Agricultural reforms - a. MBT established Diwan-i-kohi and extended Sondhar (loans) for digging wells and building canals. - b. Intention — to increase cropping area and improve cropping pattern - c. Result — Large scale corruption by officials rendered the programme useless.

Thus despite best intentions, and logical reasoning, his policies failed to bear fruits due to lack of planning and hasty withdrawl.