Give an account of the Jagirdari system of the Mughals. How was it responsible for the decline of the Mughal Empire?
Kritika Bhardwaj, AIR 370, 2023
The mansabdars of the Mughal Empire received their pay either in cash (nagd) or in the form of assignments of land from which they were entitled to collect land revenue. The system of assigning these lands (known as jagirs) was called the jagirdari system.
[two concentric circles, the inner one hatched; the outer labelled 'mansabdars' and the inner labelled 'mansabdars paid through jagir or jagirdars.']
Features of Jagirdari system 1. It traced its origins from the iqta system of Delhi Sultanate - but jagirdari system was different as it separated the fiscal and administrative rights of the concerned nobles. 2.
3. Since jagir was given in lieu of cash salary, a "standing assessment or jama" was made of all lands to be granted as jagirs (e.g) as pointed out by Abul Fazl. This jama or jamadani included the estimated land revenue, other taxes (sair jihat) and transit duties. 4. An important feature was constant/frequent transfers of jagirs (especially from Akbar reign onwards). (e.g) During the reign of Shahjahan, there were 11 successive jagirdars of Vrindavan alone. 5. Jagirdar could collect only authorised revenue (mal wajib), and for this could employ officials like amalguzar, fotadar, faujdar etc. 6.
Causing decline of the Mughal Empire : 1. 'Bejagiri' - 'Too many jagirdars chasing too few jagirs'. This problem became acute especially during Aurangzeb's reign. His focus on Deccan led to inflow of many Deccanis and Marathas as mansabdars -> causing Shortage. 2. Aurangzeb followed a policy of keeping the most lucrative jagirs under Khalisa lands. This also led to a supply-demand mismatch 3. Resistance by older nobles ('Khanzadas') who were bitterly critical of these new holders of mansabs - due to which transfers also became frequent. 4. Historians like Satish Chandra and M. Athar Ali have explained the Jagirdari crisis in context of the medieval society. They argued that the tripolar relationship between the Mughal jagirdars, zamindars and peasants destabilized leading to crisis. The difference between jamadami (assessed revenue) and hasil (actual revenue) was increasing leading to more exploitation of countryside. 5. 'Zor Talab' areas with recalcitrant zamindars who refused to pay revenue also worsened the situation. (The Agrarian crisis theory is also propounded by Irfan Habib). 6. Jagirdars, especially from Shah Jahan's reign onwards, had very low troops (Sawars). This also led to their growing inability to subjugate zamindars. Peasant revolts (e.g by Jats) also increased. 7. J.F. Richards argues that lack of Aurangzeb to effectively assimilate Maratha, Bedar, Gond and Telugu warrior chiefs led to an open rebellion.
Thus, a combination of factors in the jagirdari system led to Mughal downfall.