"Rousseau's sovereign was like Hobbesian leviathan with its head chopped off." Comment.
Kritika Bhardwaj, AIR 370, 2023
Thomas Hobbes and Jean Jacques Rousseau were influential Social thinkers and philosophers of the 17th and 18th centuries whose philosophies continue to have relevance even in present times.
Thomas Hobbes' Leviathan
- In this book, Hobbes talk about a Social contract theory in which a political community is ruled by an absolute soverign - He argues that in a "state of nature," human life would be very brutish and gruesome - where there will be "war of all against all." - Thus, to arrive at a social order, free men would have to come together and give away their Sovereignty to an absolute Soveregn. - This absolute Sovereign will keep anarchy in check and preserve peace and order.
Rousseau's Sovereign
- In his work 'The Social contract,' Rousseau talks about the need to create a social order that creates " public " good. - In this, all members of a group sacrifice their private interests for good of all.
Thus, for Rousseau, this General Will was the real sovereign.
How Rousseau's Sovereign chopped the head off of Hobbes' Sovereign
- This is because unlike Hobbe's Sovereign which could be an absolutist person -, Rousseau's idea of sovereignty doesn't have a single absolutist. The whole community becomes sovereign. - Rousseau's theory turned out to be vague, and thus prone to be misused. - No way to differentiate between general will and Absolutist will.
Thus, Rousseau's Sovereign promoted absolutism without any real power to an absolutist.