Topper Copies

What is Global Methane Pledge? Do you think the Global Methane Pledge is a positive step toward mitigating methane emissions? Explain India's stance on this issue.

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

Global Methane Pledge is a non-binding pledge to reduce methane emissions by 30% by 2030 (from 2020 level). It was launched at COP26 by the USA and countries of the EU, which have historically not met any of their pledges made earlier (eg. Kyoto).

Global Methane Pledge as a positive step 1. Methane's GWP potential is 80x CO2 in 20 years, and 20x CO2 in 100 years. The pledge will help significantly in reducing the pace of GHG emissions. 2. It will help catalyze finance towards methane (which contributes ~30% to GHG, yet has seen limited focus so far). 3. It will help in transparency in monitoring. 4. It will reduce wasteful emissions such as leakages from oil and gas fields.

Concerns 1. The main initiators of the pledge, the USA and EU, are not known to keep their climate change promises. 2. It is happening outside the ambit of the UNFCCC, an attempt by developed nations to not take responsibility via the Paris Agreement, etc (under the UNFCCC). 3. Methane has a life span of under 20 years.

India's stand 1. The agreement should be under the ambit of the UNFCCC and INDCs. 2. Indian methane emissions are "emissions of survival," NOT "emissions of luxury" (according to the Minister for Environment). 3. India is the 5th largest emitter, with only a 3.7% cumulative contribution to global warming. 4. Methane emissions in India: 50% from livestock of small and marginal farmers, 15% from paddy fields, i.e. necessary for food security and the livelihood of millions. 5. India would take steps via INDCs, and independently (eg. Harit Dhara feed, Gobar-dhan scheme, GBI, etc). India's stand is for the interests of poor and developing nations.