How far was the drain theory a focal point of nationalist critique of colonialism?
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
Drain of Wealth theory is a economic critique theory of British government first highlighted by Dadabhai Naoroji in his book 'Poverty and Unbritish rule in India'
Major features of this theory
1. It stated that the part of national product of India was repatriated back to Britain without any monetary return to Indians. 2. Various ways highlighted are - a) Payment of interest on british debt. b) Expenditure on army c) Payment of officials in london by Indian revenues. d) Guranteed returns on railways assured from Indian revenue e) Import of stationary from Britain and neglecting Indian alternatives. 3. This impeded capital formation, industrialization thus resulting in abject poverty of Indian masses.
Wealth drain as focal point of nationalist critique
1. It exposed the moral foundations, and paternalisms of british empire as mere myths. 2. It also became the core of early nationalist demands - a) Indianization of higher services. b) Reduction in military expenditure c) Import tariff protection to Indian industries. d) Expansion in size and powers of Legislative Council. 3. This theory was also helpful in maintaing and professing british loyality as it pinned the blame entirely on the government in India. 4. It also set the stage for a more mass based militant movement which was based on economic boycott of british. Eg. Swadeshi Andolan, Non-co-operation movement etc. 5. It further inspired even international events related to National movement. Eg. Lala hardayal through his Ghadr newspaper propagated this wealth drain theory to Indian expatriates in US. 6. It finally provided a socialist tinge to national movement and revolutionary movement. Eg. HSRA manifesto mentioned nationalization of industry.
Thus it was this wealth drain theory which provided Indian with ideological moorings in economic domain which defined the entire national movement in the 20th century.