Topper Copies

"James Mill, the apostle of utilitarian philosophy, proposed a revolution off Indian society through the 'weapon of law' solely. But in actual policy framing, other influences and considerations weighed much more than the colonial State." Elucidate.

Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023

Utilitarianism philosophy as popularised by Bentham and Mill involved welfare of greatest number of people through good laws and administration.

Weapon of law revolutionizing Indian society

1. Charter Act 1813 - mentioned about promotion of Indian culture, literature and kept aside ₹ 1 Lakh from budget. 2. Regulation of 1829 - by William Bentick banning Sati. 3. Widow Remarriage Act 1856 - which allowed marriage rights to widows. 4. Charter Act of 1833 - called for codification of laws. A law member (T. Macaulay) was added specially for this purpose. 5. Act of Good governance of India 1858 mentioned about responsible government under crown. 6. Other acts like Indian Enlistment Act 1856 aimed at both countering social dogana and political reasons.

Other influences on colonial state

1. Evangelicalism - it called for complete christianization of barbaric indians leading to civilization. - Charter Act 1813 allowed advent of missionaries under influence of Charles Grant 2. Capitalism which criticized mercantilism influenced by Adam Smith. Charter Acts 1813, 1833 completed ended monopoly of EIC. 3. Orientalism - prevalent during early phase, it focused on promoting Indian culture, language, history in order to Indianize alien rule. Eg) Calcutta Madrassa in 1781, Sanskrit College in 1791. - W. Hastings, W. Jones were major proponent 4. Anglicization - Completely opposite of Orientalism, aimed at teaching western education, science, culture to natives. Eg) Macaulay's Minute (1835), Cornwallis was a major proponent

Thus, a host of ideological influences determined the course of action taken by the Colonial government. Moreover, Utilitarianism was a convinient excuse aimed at legitimizing british rule which was comprehensively rejected and negated by D.B. Naoroji's wealth drain theory.