"Though the Permanent Settlement had serious defects, it gave tranquility to the countryside and stability to the government." Comment.
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
Permanent Settlement as a land revenue settlement was introduced by Lord Cornwallis in 1793 in Bengal, Bihar, Orissa and parts of Northern Madras.
Serious defects of Permanent Settlement
1. Extremely high revenue burden - which was passed on to peasants leading to further impoverishment. 2. Dispossesions of traditional Zamindar who were wiped off in auction sale. 3. Absentee landlordism since new owners like merchants, civil officers resided in cities 4. Large number of intermediaries - due to led to absentee landlordism, growing pressure on farmers. 5. Subinfudation - land was divided and further rented out to, local land owners. 6. Lack of investment - due to high revenue burden and tenure insecurity.
Tranquility to countryside
1. Relative reduction in illegal extractions by zamindars as was seen in izaredari. 2. Less number of revolts due to less burden than in izaredari system. Eg. Rangpur Dhing occured due to izaredari 3. Needs of the farmer for seed implements were met by Zamindar which was not there in izaredari.
Stability to the government
1. Fixed income - Permanent settlement reduced yearly fluctuation as seen in izaredari. 2. Reduction in corruption since revenue was fixed. limiting collector's discretion. 3. Loyal class of zamindar was created which acted as breakwater against revolts
Nonetheless, it was a highly exploitative system which completed uprooted the socio-economic relations in the countryside