Discuss the pattern of constitution changes from the Morely Minto Reform of 1909 to the Government of India Act 1935.
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
The nature and pattern of constitutional change between 1909 and 1935 has be a subject of much debate among historians even to this day
Pattern of constitutional changes between 1909 - to 1935
1. Morley Minto Reform 1909 - a.) Expanded non-official members in both central and provincial legCo. - b.) Indirect election was introduced having a very limited franchise. - c.) Communal electorate - for muslim was introduced for first time. - d.) Governors and Viceroy had wide powers of veto, ordinance etc. 2. Montague Chelmsford reform 1919 - a) Dyarchy at provincial level introduced - b) Communal electorate was extended to sikhs , anglo Indians. - c) Non-official majority at both centre and the provinces. - d) A bicameral central legCo was established for first time. 3. Government of India Act 1935 - a) Envisaged a federation of provinces and princely states. - b) Bicameral legislature at centre with dyarchy . - c) Unicameral provincial legislature having significant autonomy. - d) Significant powers of Viceroy , governors remained intact . - e) Communal electorate - was extended further to dalits and women
Various views and reactions
1. The nationalist leaders completely rejected the reforms as— - a.) Self government and dominion status was repeatedly denied. - b.) Divide Indians on caste, religious line. - c.) Excess power vested in executive without responsibility on safeguards. 2. Muslim league also decried the reforms as against self determination of muslims and pakistan resolution. 3. Historian Carl Bridge , B.R. Tomlinson opine that the sole purpose of these acts were to ensure continuation of Colonial rule by discrediting congress. 4. While Philip Woods toes official line by saying thats these acts were responsible for gradual introduction of self rule in India.
Nonetheless, there was a radical shift in [?] british policies post WWII where a genuine effort of power transfer was made in Cabinet mission 1946, Atlee's declaration and Mountbatten plan 1947 .