Evaluate the account of Fa Hien as a source of history of Ancient India. How his account can be compared with the account of Hiuen Tsang?
Rana Dey, AIR 318, 2023
Fa Hien was a chinese buddhist monk who visited major buddhist sites in ancient India during the reign of Chandragupta II in the 5th Century CE. His book 'a record of Buddhist kingdoms' provides interesting insights into ancient India.
Fa Hien accounts
1. Fa Hien provides an idealistic and idyllic viewpoint of Indian society. 2. He states that people are properous, generous, contended and do not eat meat and drink alcohol. 3. He also talks about a large festival in pataliputra which include a procession around the town. Even king participated in it. 4. He also talks about chandalas and that they had to strike a wood piece before entering town. 5. However, fa Hien provides minimal information about polity and economy as he was mainly focused on visiting buddhist site.
Hieum Tsang accounts
He provides a vivid description of Harsha era (7th century CE) in his book 'Si-Yu-ki'.
1. Political — Talks about king's daily routine and his frequent tours around the kingdom. 2. Defence — Talks about the composition of Harsha's army — consisting of infantry, cavalry, elephant, chariots etc. 3. Economy — Tsang informs us that the people were taxed lightly — about 1/6th produce - Also the king divided the revenue into 4 parts — wages, endowments, religious purpose and personal use. 4. Buddhism — Tsang talks about a grand Buddhist council at Kannauj and also his experiences in Nalanda.
Thus, it is clear that Hsung Tsang's accounts are far richer in content as compared to Fa Hien as he covered all aspects relating to that era.